Elliott from Global Unity has been involved with this project since Denver and I had a conversation with Magenta from Bloom Network last week. Both have projects that are seeking to incentives irl impact.
Perhaps all these composable pieces can fit together!
Absolutely love the idea and the visuals are fantastic, Iād vote for option 1. Any thoughts on a Nouns style auction mechanism with the ācard artā to fund this project?
Love the mechanism of community-proposed cards to drive hype.
Curious if the funding requested includes:
any formal marketing spend (ad placement, etc)?
a physical distributor/printer who youāve already scoped/understand unit economics on (not sure what the term is here for game-publisher, out of my depthā¦)?
Thanks! Nouns is one of the most elegant projects on the block. The trick is starting off with a bang. If the first one doesnāt sell for a lot of ETH the project will likely struggle. PublicNouns is working through this now.
I would like to see this project build an audience first, then embrace the Nouns model when the time is right.
Traditional marketing would likely burn the whole budget so IMO it makes sense to take a more creative and grassroots approach. The highest leverage opportunity I see is activating values-aligned people and projects to spread the word. We could incentives them by representing their projects as cards. For example, Kernel and Giveth should be represented and it would be a win/win for their communities to tweet about the cards.
I used makeplayingcards.com for the first prototype and the quality was top-notch for a reasonable price. Prices go down quickly as more cards are bought.
Thank you so much for proposing this @Colton! The ethos behind the genesis, the intended outcomes are all amazing and while I was reading, I wondered how can I get involved?
I am highly supportive of the proposal, will probably vote for option 1 to start, but this is mostly because of the desire to better understand the gameplay mechanics before committing to much.
I try to play games frequently with my son, and knowing that I can share this lore and story with him in a (hopefully) simple gameplay that reinforces why we are advancing our purpose deeply resonates.
Yes, please letās keep this work going! If you are willing, I would love to personally contribute to the process too. Perhaps I can ping you offline in how I can support?
One minor aside - Do you have any Alpha decks available for purchase yet too (the ones you handed out at Eth Denver)?
Thanks Kyle! I sent you a dm. Looking forward to building a fun game for you and your son
And for anyone else wondering about the Edition 0 decks, I donāt have any left but you can join this group for updates on future availability Telegram: Join Group Chat
This is so dope! Cant wait to see this done. What kind of card stock are you planning to use? It would be cool if the physical cards were made with cardistry in mind, in other words how they feel and look when shuffled in intersting ways. Check out this post for some examples. Non-Standard Playing Cards: A New Standard for Cardistry
I agree with the comments of all our fellow travellers in the quadratic lands in this thread and wanted to add a fidgety card jugglers perspective.
There are companies that specialize in making quality cards of these kinds. Here is one popular options.
Appreciate you proposing this @Colton. Iād say Option 1 from my end and definitely support this.
I feel a lot of the work that youāre doing is something the ecosystem honestly needs, and I believe youāre the right person to do it.
Also, the stuff that Iāve seen so far is amazing, and would love to continue seeing that come out. And definitely let me know once things are up for sale. Would love to buy stuff.
Really love this concept and was left wondering āwhere can I vote?ā ā looks like you need some more comments so Iāll say it here publicly that I support option 1.
Your creations are epic and your focus on nurturing our lore and the lore of the collective regen space is something that everyone can enjoy. Itās totally worth worth investing in.
Finally had the time to read through this. I think thereās still a lot of unknowns, (also for me personally because Iām not a gamer ) but I think if anyone deserves this funding it is you.
However, I will probably vote āabstainā, for the simple reason that I donāt think in our upcoming GCP v2 model it makes total sense for us to fund initiatives that I would consider to be purely community engagement. This post is very inspiring though, as I need to to figure out this week what the eligibility criteria for a GCP are.
In my current logic I would say this proposal belongs in the Citizens Round.
The first round is retroactive funding and you should submit your various projects separately for these Iād say.
However, I see a huge support here on your proposal (people know how much you already did for Gitcoin, and we love you for it), so that is why I would definitely not vote no, but will stick with an abstain, as more detailed rules are coming up.
For those delegating to me, I decided to vote for the $20k option instead of the $10k option. I did this as the $20k option gives an additional 10% in funding to the matching pool, and also likely gives a bit more room to develop cards and turn it into a viable game. I would hate to fund at the $10k mark and have this fail as they didnāt have enough funds to actually turn this into a playable and viable game.
Iām so thankful to @Colton for the continued support of Gitcoin and public goods. Youāve found a way to continuously orbit Gitcoin with your creativity and have done a ton to continue funding public goods through your work. Iām hopeful this is a project is successful and can get into the hands of people that may not currently be on our radar.
I had some of Coltonās cards at the Supermodular both during EthDenver and many people had an immediate connection to the artwork and the lore. It was really fun to watch. The first question people had was were can they buy a deck and the second question was how can they play.
I could see a future where we could play the game pokemon go style when we go to a different conference.
I think it is a great project, but I still think Gitcoin is spending too much money on things overall, so while i think the project has legs, I have to vote no and ideally this budget could be sourced from MMM