Context:
During a recent discussion with @MontyMerlin , a concern was raised regarding the lack of feedback mechanisms for grant applicants and the potential value of allowing donors to include notes with their donations. This suggestion aims to address these points by proposing new features for the Gitcoin platform.
Proposed Features:
-
Feedback Mechanism for Grant Applicants
As a grant applicant, I would like to:
- Have a dedicated section where I can view feedback and considerations around the decisions made on my application.
- Understand the reasons behind the acceptance or rejection of my application to improve future submissions.
Benefits:
- Provides transparency in the grant decision-making process.
- Helps applicants learn and grow from constructive feedback.
- Enhances the overall experience and trust in the Gitcoin platform.
-
Donor Notes
As a donor, I would like to:
- Have the option to add notes when making a donation.
- Provide specific feedback, encouragement, or suggestions to the grant recipients.
Benefits:
- Creates a more interactive and engaging donation experience.
- Allows for better communication and signaling between donors and projects.
- Helps grant recipients understand donor motivations and preferences.
Implementation Suggestions:
-
Feedback Mechanism:
- Integrate a feedback section in the applicant’s dashboard where they can see detailed feedback from reviewers.
- Ensure the feedback is structured, clear, and constructive.
-
Donor Notes:
- Add a text box in the donation process where donors can write notes.
- Display these notes to grant recipients in their funding overview section.
Conclusion:
Implementing these features will enhance the Gitcoin platform by fostering transparency, improving the applicant experience, and encouraging more meaningful interactions between donors and grant recipients.
debates and if you are like me join the chat at 
